There is an interesting and smart motivation in this anniversary undertaking (not that there needs to be a reason to assemble another gigantic book with powerful Magnum-quality imagery). The organization of materials is a salute to Magnum’s early days—now sixty years ago—when founders edited each other’s work. Sixty-nine members in this new volume are critiqued by a fellow agency member. Eve Arnold’s images are selected by Elliott Erwitt; Erwitt’s images are chosen by Ferdinando Scianna whose images are selected by Martine Franck; and so on.

Each photographer included is represented by six works with reflections on those images being provided by another member. Examples of other pairings include Jim Goldberg selected by Susan Meiselas, Erich Lessing by Bruno Barbey and Constantine Manos by David Alan Harvey. All this great-on-greater banter makes for heady substance, possibly because, literally, the book is so heavy. Indeed, the weight of the Magnum aura descends upon the brain while flipping through hundreds of pages filled with spectacular photographs and insightful colleague appraisals. From promising star to master to legend, the peer reviews are compelling to read and contemplating the image selections is engaging.

With this release, the agency’s lasting philosophy of the cooperative spirit, coupled with the incomparable collective vision of its photographers, is fittingly preserved. The next sixty years of photography by Magnum members is probably unimaginable. Fortunately, most will happily wait to see what’s next. Meanwhile, with its November 2007 release, Magnum Magnum is a complete collectable quickly moving to the top of many holiday gift lists.